You are currently browsing to sell us cards.

Click here to return to buying cards from us.

Sell Cards/Buylist

Please mail all buylists to:

Wizard's Tower

1-80 Marketplace Ave

Ottawa ON

K2J 5G3 

Here you can find every card we are buying and what we will pay you for it.

You will receive an email notification when we receive your cards and again when we grade your cards. 

  • Please only ship us cards that are NM. All prices shown are for NM cards. 
  • Non-Foil cards with a buylist price of 0.50 or higher will be accepted in SP(84%) and MP(68%) condition at our discretion. 
  • Basic Lands are only accepted at NM
  • Rejected cards will be returned to you at your shipping cost.
  • Cards listed as the incorrect set will not be accepted.

Only NM condition Foils will be accepted. Any Foils not in NM condition will be returned to you at your shipping cost.

We reserve the right to remove and buylist cards at any time during the process.


Why did my Buylist Change?

  • Cards could be removed from the buylist during the approval process if we already have enough copies coming in from other customers. This happens because unlike when customers buy cards from us, cards that customers are selling to us to do not get added to inventory until we receive them. This could lead to multiple customers and instances of the same card trying to be sold to us. To negate this, we may remove items from your buylist during the approval process.
  • You could see a difference in the price and grading of cards from the first processed email to the final email. This is because we do two passes for grading on all cards coming into the store for grading accuracy purposes. This could cause some cards to be corrected during the second grading process.
You can view a description of our condition guide here.
If you are not sure what condition one of your cards is in, feel free to email us a photo before submitting your order and we will be happy to give a preliminary grade. This grade is not guaranteed as scans do not always show the exact condition.

Wizard's Tower does not allow anyone to cash out any existing or new Store Credit in exchange for cash.

All rejected cards will be held for 60 days and are the responsibility of the sender to have them returned at their cost. After 60 days any rejected cards not returned to sender will be donated to local players in our community.

Please choose one of the following options to have your rejected cards returned to you:

- We can take an amount of Store Credit equal to $1.94 off of your account to have these cards returned to you immediately.  Over 60 cards could require additional postage. [Store credit can be purchased in our online store if not already present on your account]

- You can choose to pick them up in-store.

- You can place an order with our online store and have the cards mailed to you with the order you place. [If you choose this option, please make sure in the order notes that you quote the Buy Order #'s from which the returned cards would be from.]

- You can choose to leave the cards with us, and we will work on donating the cards to our new players.

We are only buying English cards right now. 
Quantities of Foils and Non Foils that we want are listed separately. We reserve the right to remove cards from the buylist at any point at our discretion.

Payment Options, Issues, & Trade Credit Bonuses

  • Paypal payments and Cheque payments are completed each Monday. For Paypal payments, if you need it sooner, you can email us to request payment. PayPal payments are sent to the email address provided upon initial buylist submission. Paypal payments are made in CAD. Paypal fees for international customers will be removed from the buylist payment.
  • We are not responsible to pay any custom costs for buylists sent to us from outside of Canada. If there is a customs fee when we receive the buylist, it will be rejected and sent back to you.
  • You can also receive a 30% bonus if you would rather trade your cards for store credit instead of cash. If you would like to trade instead of selling your cards just choose store credit as your payment option when submitting your buylist and we will issue you store credit instead of cash for your cards.